If you’re having a hard time figuring out the ingredients needed and the correct recipe to make a Pie in Grow a Garden, this guide has you covered. From Common to Mythical to Prismatic, we’ve listed all the recipes for making a Pie and feeding it to Chris P. to get those rewards you’re after.
All Recipes for Pie in Grow a Garden
The ingredients for making a Pie are very similar to the ingredients used for making a Smoothie in Grow a Garden, which is why most of the recipes listed below will only cook a Pie when it is the current craving. If Chris P. is not craving a Pie, the Common and Rare recipes will cook a Smoothie, which you can still feed to Chris P. and get a reward, as well as collect points.
| Rarity | Recipe |
|---|---|
| Common (1) | 1x Apple 1x Pumpkin |
| Common (2) | 1x Sugar Apple 1x Pumpkin 1x Giant Pinecone 1x Apple 1x Corn |
| Rare (1) | 1x Crown Melon 1x Jalapeno |
| Legendary (1) | 1x Corn 1x Coconut |
| Legendary (2) | 1x Pumpkin 1x Moon Melon |
| Legendary (3) | 1x Coconut 1x Tomato |
| Legendary (4) | 1x Pumpkin 1x Pineapple |
| Legendary (5) | 1x Pumpkin 1x Dragon Fruit |
| Legendary (6) | 1x Coconut 1x Strawberry 1x Pepper 1x Dragon Fruit |
| Mythical (1) | 1x Sugar Apple 1x Pumpkin |
| Mythical (2) | 1x Cactus 1x Cacao 1x Pumpkin 1x Peach |
| Mythical (3) | 1x Pumpkin 1x Ember Lily 1x Green Apple |
| Mythical (4) | 1x Pumpkin 1x Ember Lily |
| Mythical (5) | 1x Pumpkin 1x Giant Pinecone 1x Corn 1x Apple |
| Divine (1) | 1x Coconut 1x Beanstalk |
| Divine (2) | 1x Ember Lily 1x Beanstalk |
| Divine (3) | 2x Sugar Apple 1x Cacao 1x Ember Lily 1x Coconut |
| Divine (4) | 1x Coconut 1x Pepper 2x Elder Strawberry 1x Celestiberry |
| Divine (5) | 1x Pumpkin 3x Sugar Apple |
| Divine (6) | 1x Bone Blossom 1x Crown Melon 1x Fossilight 2x Sugar Apple |
| Prismatic (1) | 1x Pumpkin 4x Bone Blossom |
| Prismatic (2) | 1x Coconut 4x Bone Blossom |
| Prismatic (3) | 1x Coconut 1x Sugar Apple 3x Bone Blossom |
| Transcendent (1) | 1x Sugarglaze 1x Sugar Apple 2x Bone Blossom |
Aside from Bone Blossom and Fossilight, almost every other ingredient is obtainable in the game through the seed shop or the seed packs. You can obtain the other two ingredients through trading or by receiving a gift from someone.
Once you have the ingredients, put them into the cooking pot and wait for the Pie to cook. After it is ready, collect it from the pot by pressing E. Then, equip the Pie and interact with Chris P. to feed it to him. For more recipes, check out our list of All Cooking Recipes in Grow a Garden.
Shah is a Roblox specialist with years of experience covering the platform’s biggest games, updates, and code drops for top-tier gaming sites. Formerly an accountant, he now applies the same precision to analyzing mechanics, meta shifts, and game trends across the Roblox universe. He’s especially known for breaking down Blox Fruits treasure hunts and mastering the grind in Grow a Garden.