Even though there are universal likes and dislikes in Stardew Valley, some characters have very specific tastes. It's better to stick to gifts Marnie likes when you're trying to increase your liking with her.
What gifts does Marnie like in Stardew Valley?
Focus on these gifts for Marnie:
- Farmer's Lunch
- Pink Cake
- Pumpkin Pie
- All the Universal Loves
- All the Universal Likes
- And Eggs, except Void Egg
- Milk (All)
What is Marnie neutral to in Stardew Valley?
These won't really do anything if you give them to Marnie:
- Common Mushroom
- Purple Mushroom
- Snow Yam
- Winter Root
- All Fruits, except Fruit Tree Fruit and Salmonberry
What does Marnie dislike in Stardew Valley?
Avoid these gifts for Marnie:
- Wild Horseradish
There is a ranch southwest of Pelican town owned by Marnie, called Marnie's Ranch. She sells some items at her shop, but the biggest reason to go to her is to buy animals. You can multiply the effects by eight if you give her a gift on her birthday, Fall 18.