Disney Dreamlight Valley ‘The Ones That Got Away’ Quest Guide

Goofy has been our fishing pal since back when he helped us find our Royal Fishing Pole, and now it's time to do some fishing with him again in Eternity Isle. Here's where to catch all the fish he needs!

How to complete 'The Ones That Got Away' quest in Disney Dreamlight Valley

Arriving in Eternity Isle, Goofy wants to check out all the new fish that are populating the biomes. You'll start the 'The One That Got Away' quest when the quest marker pops up and you speak to him at Eternity Isle. He'll ask you to catch six fish, two each of varying species, and found only in specific locations around the Isle. Here's what you'll need:

• Dunebopper x2
• Robot Fish x2
• Prisma Shrimp x2

Before you continue the quest and track down these fish, I would suggest creating a Miracle Fishing Bait potion and bringing along a fishing companion. This will make it go a lot smoother. You can craft a Miracle Fishing Bait potion with the following ingredients:

• Vitalys Crystal x10
• Red Algae x5
• Dreamlight x500

You're only going to want to use this potion for the Robot Fish and the Prisma Shrimp. It will turn all white fishing spots into gold spots immediately. Now, you can head off and catch the fish much easier.

Where to catch Robot Fish in Disney Dreamlight Valley

Robot Fish are some of the easiest of the bunch to catch, and that's because they are found right in Ancient's Landing, in either The Docks or The Overlooks areas. However, it is only caught in gold fishing spots, so a Miracle Fishing Bait potion is handy. You should catch two very easily by using the potion and casting into white fishing spots or if you have already found gold spots.

Related: How to catch a Here and There Fish in Dreamlight Valley

Where to catch Prisma Shrimp in Disney Dreamlight Valley

The Prisma Shrimp is only caught within the Wild Tangle biome of the Isle and specifically within The Grove area, right near the ancient door waterfall. This area costs 4,000 Mist to access. Like the Robot Fish, it can be caught within gold fishing spots, also very easily done with the help of your potion.

Where to catch Dunebopper in Disney Dreamlight Valley

The Dunebopper can be caught in The Oasis within the Glittering Dunes biome. You can access this area by heading up the stairs just past the well, but it will cost 6,000 Mist to unlock. This is the only fish in the bunch that can be caught within blue fishing spots. Thankfully, even if your potion is still active, it won't affect these spots and a lot of them should pop up.

Now, you can bring those fish back to Goofy, and he will ask you to create a yummy meal using at least one of the three species that you caught. If you need some help with a recipe, you can speak to Remy or keep reading below for the best recipe to use!

Related: How to make Basil Berry Salad in Disney Dreamlight Valley

Disney Dreamlight Valley Blend of the Bayou Recipe

Goofy will give you a bunch of different ingredients to use for your meal, and you should have exactly what you need to make this dish. If you choose to speak to Remy, he will also tell you how to make it. Head to any Cooking Station and you can get started. These are the ingredients you'll need to combine:

• Celery x1
• Butter x1
• Rice x1
• Spice x1
• Prisma Shrimp x1

After you make the dish, you can head back to Goofy to tell him about it. He has also been experimenting in the kitchen and will give you a Mooncake as a reward.

Looking for more Pro Game Guides Disney Dreamlight Valley content? Check out our guides on How to unlock Goofy’s Stall on Eternity Isle in Disney Dreamlight Valley (Give Me a Sign quest) or How to catch a Crab in Dreamlight Valley!