Screenshot by Pro Game Guides

Should you give the mermaid necklace to Nerida in Hogwarts Legacy?

Here is what happens if you keep Nerida's mermaid necklace!

In Hogwarts Legacy, you can either keep or return Nerida Robert's mermaid Necklace. Here is what happens in both choices and how to complete the Mer-Ky Depths quest given to you by the Slytherin student.

Recommended Videos

Should you keep or return Nerida's mermaid necklace in Hogwarts Legacy?

Screenshot by Pro Game Guides

You will meet Nerida Roberts for the first time in the Hogwarts Boathouse, where she gives you the Mer-Ky Depths quest. In the mission, the Slytherin student asks you to swim underwater and retrieve a necklace that the merpeople have left her as a peace offering. After retrieving the mermaid gift, you will be given the choice of either giving the necklace back to Nerida or keeping it all for yourself. Similar to the Hogwarts Legacy Zenobia Gobstone quest, though, your decision has little consequence.

Related: All Daedalian Key locations in Hogwarts Legacy

Both choices have the same reward: 180 experience points and the Mermish Liason Uniform. So regardless of what you do, the outcome will largely be the same. However, if you keep the mermaid necklace, Nerida Roberts will be upset with you for potentially ruining the relationship between merpeople and wizardkind. While this sounds like a big deal, it ultimately has no consequences as Hogwarts Legacy doesn't have a relationship system, and there aren't any further missions with Nerida. You can't do anything with the mermaid necklace either, so feel free to choose whichever option you like the most.

How to complete Mer-Ky Depths quest in Hogwarts Legacy

Screenshot by Pro Game Guides

After speaking with Nerida, swim in the water to the marked waypoint to dive under the lake. You will see a locked moth door once you've emerged into the cavern. To complete Mer-Ky Depths, use the Incendio spell on the cobwebs to free the two trapped moths. Next, use Lumos to carry each insect to the door to lock them into place.

The final moth can be found behind a pillar at the back of the room, so circle back to the entrance to grab it. With all three insects in place, the door will automatically unlock to reveal a chest. Open the treasure to retrieve the mermaid necklace and return it to Nerida. You will now be given the choice to either keep or give the gift to Nerida. After making your decision, the Mer-Ky Depths quest will be completed.

For more information on Hogwarts Legacy, check out Where to get Fwoopers and Fwooper Feathers in Hogwarts Legacy here on Pro Game Guides.

Pro Game Guides is supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission. Learn more about our Affiliate Policy
Image of Brent Koepp
Brent Koepp
Brent Koepp is a freelance games journalist based out of California. An avid Pokemon fan for over 25 years, he has spent his career reporting on the popular Nintendo franchise. He also dabbles in Destiny 2 and JRPGs. You can follow him on Twitter @brentrkoepp.

Write A Comment

Should you give the mermaid necklace to Nerida in Hogwarts Legacy?

Comments are on moderation and will be approved in a timely manner. Please read the following rules before commenting:

  • All comments must be on topic and add something of substance to the post
  • No swearing or inappropriate words
  • No asking or begging for anything free
  • Do not attempt to start a poll in the comments
  • Comments in all CAPS will be removed
  • We reserve the right to remove a comment for any reason
  • Do not impersonate a staff member or influencer

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.